My work survives entirely on your generosity. Thanks In Advance For your donation.
Please Top Up My Coffee
https://www.paypal.com/donate/?hosted_button_id=PPKN4BRCN9MSL
Chapter 1
Of course, there is no tree that actually grows an apple called the teacher's apple. Yet across the country, many such apples sprout on teachers' desks every morning, mostly placed there with very nice intentions. Then, there are the ones that are not.
Consider the famous fairy tale apple, conjured by a wicked witch and served to Snow White for ill ends. It is an odd coincidence, then, that the teacher in question at Jewel Lake High was Miss Izabell Snow, a woman who resembled the storybook Snow White in an uncanny way. Even odder was what happened when she took a bite of the glossy red fruit waiting on her blotter on a crisp Tuesday morning.
She died.
The trouble was, nobody knew who had placed the apple on her desk. Not the principal, not the hall monitors, and certainly not the local police. Every hallway camera had a blind spot, every student had an alibi, and the trail went cold before the third-period bell even rang.
That is where I came in.
I go by Alley Kat. It is a play on my real name, Alice Katlin, my official byline here at The Jewel Lake Herald, and a nod to my knack for slipping through shadows where no shadows ought to exist. I have a habit of discovering things in places where everyone else insists there is nothing left to find.
In this case, the police were looking for a poisoner. I had to discover something far trickier: who in our quiet little town would ever want to do harm to Miss Snow, and why they chose a fairytale way to do it.
My experience in the art of newspaper investigations started with an innocent little diary I began keeping at the age of nine. By the time I hit middle school, I was already writing full articles for our school paper, The Jewel Lake Herald Jr. I had plenty of guidance along the way from my uncle, who owns and operates the town's main paper, The Jewel Lake Gazette, a business I fully intend to inherit some day.
Jewel Lake seems to be one of those places naturally prone to mysteries. They are not always murder, mind you, though they are often dastardly in nature and far too frequently end with fatal results, even when no actual crime was intended.
At this point, I have several years of solid experience in sniffing out hidden information and piecing together stray clues. Even the local police sort of let me go off on my tangents, despite the official rule that I am not supposed to interfere. The truth is, Jewel Lake has no dedicated detectives on the payroll, just a handful of uniform officers who play at the job until the provincial police finally get involved. By the time the brass arrives from out of town, I have usually figured the whole thing out and quietly handed over my results.
Here and now, however, I must admit that the apple case was a genuine baffler.
Chapter 2
To begin at the start: Everyone saw the apple sitting on Miss Snow’s desk that morning. It was big, glossy, and beautifully polished. When I first laid eyes on it during homeroom, I felt a sharp little tingle, maybe it was even a premo (slang for premonition, for those not in the know). But like a fool, I shrugged it off and got on with the usual morning announcements.
By noon, the apple was gone, and so was Miss Snow.
The word going around was that she had stepped out for a meeting somewhere across town. A meeting, I learned in due course, that she never actually reached.
By the time the sixth-period bell rang, the local constables had already packed up their notebooks and cleared out of Room 204, leaving behind a faint smell of wet wool and chalk dust. They had questioned the class as a herd, which is the worst possible way to get the truth out of high schoolers. Put thirty teenagers in a room with a badge and everyone suddenly develops selective amnesia.
I waited until the hall monitor ducked into the washroom, slipped back inside, and perched right on the edge of Miss Snow's empty desk.
"Alright, folks," I said, flipping open my spiral notebook and tapping my pencil against the cover. "The uniforms are gone, and The Jewel Lake Herald goes to print tomorrow morning. Somebody in here saw that apple land on the blotter before the first bell. Who was it?"
Silence stretched across the rows of scarred wooden desks. Nobody wanted to be a snitch, and nobody wanted to look guilty.
I started with Toby Vance in the front row. Toby is always the first kid through the door because he likes to copy the homework off the board before homeroom starts.
"Toby," I said, leaning forward just enough to let my leather jacket creak. "You were sitting here when I walked in at ten to eight. Was the apple already there?"
Toby adjusted his thick glasses and swallowed hard. "Yeah, Alice. Honest. It was sitting right next to her attendance binder when I came in. I didn't touch it, I swear. I don't even like fruit."
"Nobody thinks you poisoned a teacher over a pop quiz, Toby. Did you see anyone leaving the room when you walked up the hall?"
He frowned, staring up at the fluorescent lights. "Just Brenda."
Every head in the third row turned toward Brenda Miller. Brenda is the self-appointed queen of the sophomore drama club, usually decked out in enough pastel sweaters to stock a department store. Today, however, her eyes were red-rimmed, and she was shredding a paper tissue into confetti on her desk.
"I didn't put it there!" Brenda blurted out before I even opened my mouth. "I just went in to drop off my late slip for yesterday's dentist appointment. The apple was already sitting there, shiny as a bowling ball. Actually, I thought maybe you put it there, Alice, since you're always hovering around for stories."
"Not my style, Brenda. If I bring a teacher an apple, it has a worm in it and a headline attached." I jotted a quick note in my margin. "So if it was there before Toby and before Brenda, that puts the delivery window between seven-thirty, when the janitor unlocks the wing, and seven-forty-five."
I turned my gaze toward the back corner by the radiator, where Marcus "Tank" Kowalski was slumped so low in his chair his knees were practically touching his chin. Marcus plays left tackle for the Jewel Lake Timberwolves, and he is usually the guy everyone looks at whenever something goes missing or gets broken.
"You're awfully quiet back there, Marcus," I said, softening my voice just a touch. "You usually get dropped off early with the track team."
Marcus grunted, refusing to meet my eyes. "I wasn't in the hallway, Kat. I was in the gym."
"Funny," I replied, flipping a page in my pad. "Coach Henderson told the cops the gym doors were locked until eight o'clock sharp because the boiler was acting up."
Marcus stiffened. A slow red flush crept up his neck, and for a second I thought he was going to bolt. Instead, he let out a long, defeated sigh and stared down at his scuffed sneakers.
"Alright, fine," he muttered, keeping his voice low so only the back rows could hear. "I was in the hall around seven-thirty-five. I was trying to slip a note into Sarah Jenkins' locker before morning announcements."
A few kids snickered, and Sarah, two rows over, went bright pink. I held up a hand to quiet them down. "Did you see anyone go into Miss Snow's room, Marcus?"
"No," he said, shaking his head. "The corridor was dead empty. Except..." He paused, squinting as he tried to picture the hallway. "Well, the door to 204 wasn't closed all the way, and I smelled something weird drifting out into the hall. Not perfume. Something sweet and sharp, like burnt almonds and wintergreen. And when I walked past the window in the door, the apple was already sitting on her desk."
I scribbled down burnt almonds and wintergreen and underlined it twice.
If the janitor unlocked the wing at seven-thirty, and the apple was already sitting on the blotter by seven-thirty-five without a single student setting foot in the room, then our phantom fruit-bearer wasn't one of my classmates at all. It was someone who already had a key to the building.
Chapter 3
After the final bell rang, I traded my scuffed boots for a pair of low-heeled loafers I keep stashed in my locker, swapped the leather jacket for a neat plaid blazer, and brushed the chalk dust off my skirt. If you want to get past a downtown receptionist without a press pass that actually carries weight, looking like an eleventh-grade tomboy won't cut it. Looking like a conscientious honours student running an errand for the school office, on the other hand, works wonders.
Mr. Arthur Galahar's office sat on the second floor of the old brick block overlooking Main Street, sandwiched between an insurance agency and a dental clinic. The frosted glass on his door read Galahar & Associates: Private Wealth & Investment Counsel in gold leaf that had seen better decades.
Inside, the waiting room smelled of floor wax and stale coffee. A grey-haired receptionist looked up from her typewriter over half-moon spectacles.
"Can I help you, dear?" she asked.
"Good afternoon," I said, pitching my voice polite and slightly breathless, like I had hurried all the way from the high school. "I'm Alice Katlin from Jewel Lake High. Principal Henderson sent me down to pick up the folder Miss Snow was supposed to review with Mr. Galahar at noon today. Since she didn't make it, he wanted to make sure her paperwork wasn't left sitting out."
The woman frowned, flipping through a leather-bound desk diary. "Miss Izabell Snow? Yes, she was pencilled in for twelve-fifteen. We waited until almost one o'clock, and she never showed up or called. Very unlike her. Let me check with Mr. Galahar to see if she left anything behind from her last visit."
She disappeared through a heavy mahogany door, leaving it ajar just wide enough for me to hear a low, gravelly voice bark, "What do you mean, a girl from the school?"
A moment later, the door swung open and Arthur Galahar stepped out himself. He was a broad-shouldered man in his late fifties wearing a three-piece charcoal suit that looked far too expensive for a town like Jewel Lake, with silver hair slicked back and eyes as sharp as a hawk's.
"I'm Arthur Galahar," he said, offering a tight, practiced smile that didn't quite reach his eyes. "My secretary says you're asking about Izabell Snow. Did something happen to her? We heard sirens heading toward the river road around lunchtime."
"There's been an incident at the school, sir," I replied carefully, clutching my spiral notebook against my chest like a school binder. "The police are still sorting things out, so I'm just trying to tie up loose ends for the administration. What was Miss Snow coming to see you about today?"
Galahar's jaw tightened for a fraction of a second before the smooth broker mask slid back into place. "Client confidentiality prevents me from discussing the particulars of Miss Snow's portfolio, young lady. Even with the school."
"Of course," I said, nodding sympathetically. "It's just odd. Everyone at the school thought Miss Snow lived strictly on a teacher's salary. Nobody knew she had an investment broker."
"People often keep their private affairs private," Galahar said smoothly, resting one hand on the doorframe as if ushering me toward the exit. "All I can tell you is that she called my office yesterday afternoon in quite a hurry to book an urgent midday appointment. She said she had come into possession of a family asset she wanted liquidated immediately, before the end of the week."
My ears perked up. "A family asset? Like property, or stocks?"
"She wouldn't say over the phone. Simply told me to have cash transfer paperwork ready for noon today." Galahar glanced at his gold wristwatch, his tone turning brisk. "Now, if you'll excuse me, I have a client on the line from Toronto. You can tell Principal Henderson I have no paperwork belonging to Miss Snow in my possession."
He stepped back and clicked the mahogany door shut.
I thanked the receptionist, walked calmly down the wooden stairs to Main Street, and didn't pull out my pencil until I was safely tucked inside the doorway of the hardware store across the street.
Miss Snow hadn't gone out for a routine luncheon or a parent-teacher errand. She had been rushing to cash out a mysterious family asset on twenty-four hours' notice, and somebody had made sure she took a bite of that glossy red apple before she ever got the chance to tell Arthur Galahar what it was.
Chapter 4
If you want to understand why a quiet history teacher suddenly decides to liquidate a mysterious family asset on twenty-four hours' notice, you don't look in her classroom. You look where she keeps the things she doesn't want the rest of Jewel Lake to see.
Miss Snow rented the upper flat of a clapboard duplex on Cedar Street, three blocks back from the lakefront. By the time I pedalled my bike up the gravel drive just after four o'clock, the local constables had already taped a single strip of yellow plastic across the front porch steps and gone back to the detachment to fill out their afternoon reports.
Mrs. Higgins, the retired landlady who lived downstairs, was sweeping dead pine needles off the lower walkway with the grim determination of a woman trying to sweep away a scandal.
"Afternoon, Mrs. Higgins," I called out, pulling my spiral notebook from my blazer pocket and letting my press badge from The Jewel Lake Herald catch the late afternoon sun. "Terrible business about Miss Snow. My uncle at the Gazette asked me to put together a proper tribute piece for Friday's edition, and I wanted to make sure we got her biographical details right."
Mrs. Higgins paused, leaning on her broom handle with a heavy sigh. "Poor Izabell. Kept to herself, paid her rent on the first of every month in crisp bills, and never made a peep upstairs. The police went through her things an hour ago, Alice, so I'm not supposed to let anyone up there."
"I wouldn't dream of disturbing a thing," I said earnestly. "I just wondered if she had any next of kin we ought to notify before the paper runs her obituary."
The older woman shook her head. "Not a soul, as far as I know. She told me when she moved in three years ago that all her people were gone. Though if you want to take a quick peek at the mantelpiece in her parlour, she kept an old framed photograph up there. Maybe there's a name written on the back. Just don't touch anything, and if a cruiser pulls up, you came to ask me about the church bake sale."
Five minutes later, I was standing in the quiet, sunlit living room of Miss Snow's flat.
The place was immaculate, furnished with secondhand oak pieces, neatly stacked history journals, and a single bowl of wax fruit on the coffee table that made my stomach turn just looking at it. Over the brick fireplace sat the silver-framed photograph Mrs. Higgins had mentioned.
I leaned in close without lifting it off the shelf. It was a slightly faded colour snapshot taken sometime in the late 1990s in front of a weathered lakeside cabin. A stern-looking man in a flannel shirt stood beside a pale, dark-haired woman who looked like an older twin of Miss Snow herself. Standing in front of them were three children: a teenage Izabell, a younger boy with bright red hair, and a little girl clutching a stuffed rabbit.
That stopped me cold. Mrs. Higgins said Miss Snow had told everyone her whole family was gone. Yet here were a mother, a father, and two younger siblings staring straight into the camera.
I pulled a pencil from behind my ear and carefully used the eraser tip to nudge the corner of the frame sideways, peering behind the cardboard backing. Tucked neatly between the frame and the wall was a folded yellow receipt from a safety deposit box at the Northern Trust Bank in Sudbury, dated three days ago, alongside a torn corner of an old newspaper clipping.
The clipping was half-burned at the edges, as if someone had once tried to destroy it and changed their mind. Only three lines of newsprint remained legible:
...MINE COLLAPSE CLAIMS TWO LIVES AT QUIRKE RIDGE; THIRD SURVIVOR VANISHES WITH PAYROLL STRONG-BOX...
Beneath the headline, written in Miss Snow's neat, teacherly cursive in blue ink, were four initials and a date from twenty-five years ago.
I copied every letter into my notebook, eased the silver frame back into place so the eraser left not a smudge behind, and slipped back down the stairs.
Miss Snow hadn't come into a harmless family heirloom. Somebody in that faded photograph had survived a twenty-five-year-old mining disaster with a stolen strong-box, and whichever sibling was still out there had just silenced Izabell before she could turn their secret into cash.
Chapter 5
Of course, all of that was pure speculation, and speculation doesn't get you very far when you're trying to nail down a killer before the provincial police take over the case. So I stopped guessing and started digging deeper, rifling through Miss Snow's private drawers and invading her quiet, tidy life just to understand how she actually lived it.
Mrs. Higgins had gone down to the basement to start a load of laundry, leaving me alone with the secondhand oak furniture and the faint smell of lavender soap. I pulled on a pair of thin cotton gloves I keep tucked in my coat pocket for messy errands and went to work on her writing desk.
The top drawers held nothing more scandalous than red grading pens, spare attendance sheets, and neat bundles of electric bills paid three weeks ahead of schedule. The bottom drawer on the right, however, had a brass lock that didn't quite catch when you jiggled the handle.
Inside, buried beneath a stack of old Ontario history textbooks, was a small, leather-bound address book with a gold clasp. Most of the entries were written in Miss Snow's precise, flowing cursive: the school board office, a dentist in Sudbury, a florist down on Main Street.
Then I flipped to the back pages.
Scrawled across the final sheet in thick, hurried pencil, nothing at all like Izabell's careful penmanship, was a single name and a local phone exchange: Julian Mercer, General Delivery, Jewel Lake.
I stared at the page until the letters practically lifted off the paper.
In doing so, I had just brought the whole mess a whole lot closer to home. In a town the size of Jewel Lake, everybody knows everybody else's family tree going back three generations, and there had never been a Mercer in this district since the first timber roads were cut in the fifties.
I pocketed my notebook, slipped quietly back down Mrs. Higgins' stairs, and pedalled straight to my uncle's office at The Jewel Lake Gazette, where the town's property rolls, new utility hookups, and business registries sit in big green binders behind the counter.
Twenty minutes of cross-referencing confirmed what my gut was already telling me. Julian Mercer was brand new in town. He had rented a furnished cabin out near the old Quirke Ridge access road six weeks ago, paid six months' rent up front in cash, and left the employment and previous-address lines on his lease completely blank.
He was a ghost with a fresh coat of paint, a name with no real backstory at all. And if you looked closely enough at the timeline, he had arrived in Jewel Lake right around the same time Miss Snow started making trips to a safety deposit box in Sudbury.
Chapter 6
I pedalled out past the edge of town just before dusk to track down Julian Mercer, hoping to catch him off guard before he had time to pack his bags and slip away into the northern bush. The sky above Jewel Lake had bruised into a deep slate purple, and the gravel along the old Quirke Ridge road crunched loudly beneath my tires. Every peddle stroke felt like a race against the clock. Once the provincial detectives rolled into town from Sudbury with their crime-scene tape and jurisdictional badges, my unofficial press pass wouldn't get me past the front gate.
Mercer's rented cabin sat tucked behind a dense stand of jack pines about two miles past the last municipal streetlight, half-hidden from the main lane. I leaned my bike against a mossy boulder out of sight from the road and approached on foot, keeping to the soft needle-strewn shoulder. No pickup truck sat in the rutted drive, no chimney smoke curled into the grey evening air, and the windows stared back at me like dark, empty eyes. When I climbed the sagging wooden steps and knocked sharply on the warped screen door, the only answer was the autumn wind rattling the loose porch boards.
I cupped my hands against the dusty glass of the front window and peered inside. The main room was completely deserted. Trying the tarnished brass knob, I felt the latch give easily; the deadbolt hadn't even been thrown.
Pulling my thin cotton gloves back on before touching a single surface, I stepped across the threshold and let the door click softly shut behind me. The air inside smelled stale, a mix of damp pinewood, cold grease, and cheap aftershave. Whoever had cleared out of here had left in a blind, desperate hurry. Half-empty cardboard takeout containers sat congealing on the laminate kitchen table beside a cold mug of black coffee, a half-eaten egg roll still resting on a paper napkin. Over on the sagging plaid sofa lay an open canvas suitcase, stuffed haphazardly with wrinkled flannel shirts, tangled socks, and work trousers that badly needed a laundromat.
I took a slow step toward the kitchen counter, my eyes scanning the floorboards for any sign of a ledger, a bank receipt, or a key to that Sudbury safety deposit box. Instead, I looked down at the scuffed linoleum beside the coffee table, and my stomach churned.
Right next to an overturned wooden chair was a dark, tacky patch of blood, roughly the size of a dinner plate. A faint, ragged smear dragged away from the puddle toward the back mudroom door, where a boot heel had skidded across the floor in a panic.
My throat went dry. I backed slowly out onto the front porch and leaned against the wooden railing to catch my breath, the evening chill suddenly biting straight through my plaid blazer. Mercer hadn't simply packed up and skipped town after poisoning his sister. Someone else had come to this cabin, cornered him before he could finish throwing his laundry into his bag, and dragged him out into the woods, or worse.
Yet as I stood there in the gathering dark, listening to the jack pines creak overhead, a far colder thought hit me than the sight of that blood on the linoleum.
If Julian Mercer was either dead or bleeding out somewhere in the bush, then who was pulling the strings? Worse still, what mattered even more was the rumor my uncle had whispered to me in the back room of the Gazette office just before I grabbed my bike: the ambulance crew that responded to Jewel Lake High at noon had never actually delivered Izabell Snow to the county morgue. Somewhere between the schoolhouse steps and the river road, the stretcher had vanished, and Miss Snow had disappeared.
Chapter 7
I did the responsible thing. I pedalled straight down to the detachment on Main Street and went to the local police with everything I had found at the Quirke Ridge cabin. Not that they were likely to do much on their own now that they had officially handed the file over to the provincial police, who were supposedly already on their way from Sudbury, but at least I figured they might put out an immediate local search for Julian Mercer before the trail went completely cold.
Sergeant Miller took down my statement with a weary sigh, thanked me for not touching the doorknob without gloves, and promised to send a cruiser out to the cabin to secure the perimeter until the province arrived.
As I walked my bike back home along the darkening sidewalk toward Cedar Street, however, something very odd swept through my thoughts, stopping me dead in my tracks beneath the flickering glow of a streetlamp.
All afternoon, the whole town had been whispering about murder. Yet when I replayed every conversation from the homeroom corridor to Galahar's office, I realized no one had ever actually said outright that Miss Snow was dead. Every rumour had simply snowballed from the fact that she had collapsed after eating that glossy red apple, and that it seemed she had been poisoned.
Even in my own opening column notes, I had jumped straight to the fairy-tale ending without checking the medical facts.
Instead of turning onto my street, I swung my bike around and headed three blocks south to the clapboard house with the brass shingle beside the front porch: Dr. Arthur Pendelton, the town's longtime physician and county coroner.
I found him on his front veranda, nursing a mug of tea in the cool evening air. When I asked him point-blank what the poison had been, the old doctor simply shook his head and let out a dry, tired chuckle.
"I couldn't tell you if I wanted to, Alice," Dr. Pendelton said, setting his mug down on the porch railing. "I never actually got the chance to examine her. When the ambulance crew loaded her onto the gurney outside Room 204, I took one quick look at her face before they closed the rear doors. I just saw her lips were blue, and in my line of work, blue lips sometimes says poison. I told the driver to run straight for the regional hospital in Sudbury for a proper toxicology screen, and that was the last I laid eyes on her."
I stood on his bottom step, my spiral notebook suddenly feeling very heavy in my pocket.
Blue lips didn't just mean poison. Blue lips meant a lack of oxygen, a severe allergic shock, or a dozen other things that could make a woman look dead as a doornail without actually killing her, especially if she wanted the entire town of Jewel Lake to believe she was gone.
Chapter 8
Walking back from Dr. Pendelton's veranda, the pieces of this crazy jigsaw puzzle finally began snapping together in my head with a click loud enough to echo down Cedar Street.
Miss Snow wasn't dead, because Miss Snow had never really existed in the first place.
The whole thing was a magic trick, plain and simple, staged right under the noses of three hundred high school kids, a seasoned faculty, and a town full of armchair detectives. She had needed to vanish into thin air, and she had needed to vanish cleanly, without anyone looking for a runaway schoolteacher, so that someone else could step onto the stage in Jewel Lake. Someone like Julian Mercer.
Instead of heading home for supper, I doubled back to the clapboard duplex on Cedar Street. Mrs. Higgins' downstairs curtains were drawn tight against the evening chill, the blue glow of her television flickering faintly behind the lace. Slipping around the side porch like an alley cat in the dark, I eased open the unlocked back stairwell door and crept silently up to Miss Snow's flat once more.
With my cotton gloves pulled snug over my fingers and a small penlight clicked on between my teeth, I went back to work on her bedroom closet and the bottom drawers of her bureau, rifling through every stack of papers, old teaching certificates, and shoeboxes I had skipped during my rushed afternoon sweep.
The deeper I dug, the clearer the illusion became. Her Ontario teaching credentials were printed on crisp, heavy bond paper dated five years ago, yet there were no college yearbooks, no childhood keepsakes, no old letters from former classmates, and not a single scrap of paper bearing the name Izabell Snow prior to the autumn she arrived to teach history at Jewel Lake High. Every bank statement, lease agreement, and utility receipt began five years earlier, as if she had stepped off the Greyhound bus out of nowhere fully formed.
Then, tucked inside the lining of an old cedar hatbox on the top shelf of her wardrobe, my gloved fingers brushed against a stiff cardboard folder. Inside were three crisp passport-style photographs of Izabell Snow, except in two of them, her dark hair was tucked up beneath a men's tweed cap, her eyebrows were pencilled thicker, and a theatrical spirit-gum moustache shadowed her upper lip. Beside the photos lay a folded theatrical supply receipt from a costume shop in Toronto and a slender glass vial, half-empty, stoppered with cork.
I stared at the vial under the narrow beam of my penlight, and suddenly I remembered what Marcus Kowalski had told me back in Room 204 about the strange scent drifting out of the classroom doorway at seven-thirty-five that morning.
Burnt almonds and wintergreen.
It wasn't cyanide, and it wasn't rat poison. Any kid who has ever hung around the high school drama club knows what wintergreen oil and bitter almond extract smell like when mixed with theatrical stage greasepaint and a mild sedative capsule designed to drop a person's blood pressure just enough to turn their lips pale blue for twenty minutes.
She had planted that glossy red apple on her own desk before seven-thirty just to get the entire school talking about a fairy-tale poisoning. Then, right around noon, she had stepped out of Room 204 claiming she was heading downtown to meet Arthur Galahar, bitten into her doctored apple in the side corridor where the ambulance crew could scoop her up on cue, and walked straight out the back of that rigged ambulance before it ever reached the Sudbury highway.
Miss Snow hadn't been murdered by Julian Mercer. She had shed Izabell Snow like an old winter coat so she could become Julian Mercer, and whoever had attacked her out at the Quirke Ridge cabin had come looking for the real survivor of that twenty-five-year-old mine collapse.
Chapter 9
But all of that was still just conjecture, and the real truth was still sitting out there in the dark, waiting for me to catch up. When it finally arrived, it didn't come through a magnifying glass or a dusty ledger. It hit me bolt upright in bed like a three-in-the-morning epiphany, so sharp and ridiculous I actually laughed out loud into my quiet bedroom.
I had been looking at the whole masquerade backwards.
Miss Snow hadn't staged a fake poisoning so she could disappear and become a man. She had staged a fake poisoning because she could never, under any circumstances, allow herself to be examined on a hospital gurney or a county slab. Even the dumbest, half-asleep morgue attendant in Sudbury would have noticed within ten seconds that Miss Izabell Snow wasn't a she at all.
That was why Dr. Pendelton had only been given a two-second glimpse of blue lips through the back doors of a moving ambulance before the crew slammed the latch and sped off toward the highway. A proper examination would have blown five years of careful camouflage wide open. She had to disappear into thin air because she had been Julian Mercer, or rather, the man behind Julian Mercer, the entire time.
I swung my legs out of bed, flicked on my desk lamp, and stared at my spiral notebook, where I had copied down the torn newspaper headline from behind the mantelpiece photograph.
MINE COLLAPSE CLAIMS TWO LIVES AT QUIRKE RIDGE; THIRD SURVIVOR VANISHES WITH PAYROLL STRONG-BOX.
Suddenly, the question of who Julian Mercer really was jumped up in my brain like a spring-loaded jester in a joke shop.
If the man masquerading as Izabell Snow had stolen the Quirke Ridge payroll strong-box twenty-five years ago and spent five years hiding in plain sight as a quiet small-town history teacher while waiting for the mining company's old audit trails to go cold and the original investigators to retire, then why create a second identity as Julian Mercer six weeks ago? Because you can't walk into a Sudbury bank or an investment broker's office wearing a wig and a floral skirt to liquidate a quarter-century-old stash of stolen bearer bonds or gold bullion without raising every red flag in northern Ontario. He had rented that cabin out by Quirke Ridge as a staging ground to shed Miss Snow for good and step back into his own skin as Julian Mercer to cash out with Arthur Galahar.
It just kept getting more absurd, layer after layer, like a set of painted wooden dolls where every face hid another stranger underneath.
Yet one jagged piece still refused to fit inside the box. If Miss Snow was actually a man who had pulled off the most audacious disappearing act in Jewel Lake history just to step into Julian Mercer's boots, then whose blood was drying on the linoleum floor of that cabin out by Quirke Ridge, and who had dragged him out into the bush before he could ever collect his fortune?
Chapter 10
By breakfast, the final curtain dropped on the whole theatrical production, and it turned out Julian Mercer wasn't real either.
Mercer had never been the end of the disguise; he was just another disposable paper mask built to take the fall. Once the Quirke Ridge strong-box had been quietly cleared out of the Sudbury safety deposit box, Julian Mercer had to disappear just as cleanly as Izabell Snow had. So another mirage was constructed out at the jack-pine cabin: an overturned chair, a half-packed suitcase, and a dinner-plate splash of theatrical stage blood on the linoleum, just enough smoke and carnival mirrors to send the provincial police combing the northern bush for a missing corpse that never existed.
With no body ever found and Mercer vanished into thin air, the authorities were ready to chalk the whole affair up as a gangland execution out in the pines. They would have stayed fooled, too, if I hadn't decided to stake out Main Street from the doorway of the hardware store across from Galahar & Associates the following afternoon.
At two o'clock sharp, a broad-shouldered man in a sharp grey topcoat and neatly trimmed beard stepped off the afternoon bus from Sudbury and walked straight up the wooden stairs into the financier's office. I followed quietly up the landing, pressed my ear to the frosted glass, and nearly dropped my spiral notebook when I recognized the voice inside.
It was Harold Higgins, Mrs. Higgins' quiet, unassuming son from downstairs on Cedar Street, the man who supposedly worked out of town as a travelling timber surveyor and always dropped by on Sunday afternoons to mow his mother's lawn.
I didn't need a search warrant to put the remaining pieces together. Harold Higgins had been living right downstairs from "Izabell Snow" the entire time, using the upper flat as a daytime costume trunk and the lower flat as his real home base. He had staged the Snow White apple at school to bury the schoolteacher, rigged the bloody cabin at Quirke Ridge to bury Julian Mercer, and walked straight into Arthur Galahar's office in his own skin to collect the liquidated payroll fortune as a legitimate local businessman.
Ten minutes later, when the provincial detectives finally arrived at Galahar's door with the warrant I had tipped them off to secure, Harold Higgins didn't even run. He simply adjusted his cuffs, looked at me standing beside the sergeant with my spiral notebook open, and offered a slow, grudging tip of his hat.
By Friday morning, The Jewel Lake Herald ran my full account across the front page under the headline The Mystery of the Teacher's Apple. Everyone in town agreed it was the strangest case Jewel Lake had ever seen, though if you ask me, the strangest part of all is how easily people will swallow a fairy tale, provided you polish the apple bright enough before you set it on the desk.